Over the past several years, Pennsylvania’s General Assembly has seen a number of online gambling bills come and go. As the industry grew in New Jersey, it was thought that the Keystone State, which boasts the second biggest gambling market in the US, would soon pass iGaming legislation of its own. But the details proved difficult to iron out, with competing interests sinking legislation year after year. That all changed on Thursday morning, however, when PA lawmakers reached a consensus and finally legalized Internet gambling along with daily fantasy sports (DFS).
The enticing revenues posted by NJ online casinos was without a doubt a factor in helping that legislation along. New Jersey has also served as an example and provided a roadmap for Pennsylvania, which will structure its iGaming industry much like the Garden State has structured its own. Here’s where the two states converge and where they will differ.
Who’s allowed to participate?
In both PA and NJ, only brick-and-mortar casinos already licensed can apply for an online gambling permit. In the Commonwealth, that means 12 casinos will have the chance to acquire a license. Once approved, PA casinos will be allowed to partner with outside gambling software providers, similar to the relationship between GVC and NJ’s Borgata Casino, for example.
Which games are available?
Both states allow operators to offer online slots, table games and peer to peer poker sites. DFS operators are also able to set up shop in the two states, provided they partner with a licensed casino.
PA a potential boon to US online poker
Earlier this month, Gov. Chris Christie announced a deal between NJ, Nevada and Delaware to share online poker player pools, thus creating the potential for a much more vibrant and sustainable online poker community. Pennsylvania, which has a population bigger than those three states combined, will surely buy into the same compact, potentially doubling existing player pools.
Expect many of the companies which have current relationships in NJ to forge partnerships with the same companies in Pennsylvania. 888 provides the platform for several Caesars Entertainment Corp. entities in the Garden State, so it’s likely we’ll see Harrah’s Philadelphia continue that partnership in PA.
Taxation and licensing fees
One area where PA and NJ iGaming differ wildly is in regards to tax rates and licensing fees. In New Jersey, operators can snag an interactive gaming license for $400,000, while in Pennsylvania the cost will be an eye watering $10 million. The $10 million figure will allow casinos to offer three categories of games: online slots, table games and poker. If they prefer, they can choose a piecemeal approach, and buy individual licenses for $4 million.
Pennsylvania’s brick-and-mortar casinos are taxed at an extremely high rate in comparison with NJ. Garden State properties pay 9.25 percent tax on all games across the board, while Commonwealth casinos pay 55 percent for slots and 16 percent for table games.
Excessive PA online slots tax a blow
The state’s high land-based tax rate is what purportedly led PA lawmakers to make a seemingly huge mistake, which could cripple its online gambling industry before it even gets off the ground. NJ taxes its iGaming operators at a rate of 17.5 percent for all games, while the PA bill calls for the same 55 percent rate for online slots. Table games and poker remain at 16 percent.
Slots being the biggest money makers in online gambling, the excessive tax will stymie the industry and possibly even cause some operators to stay out entirely, leaving less revenue for the state. In its shortsighted attempt to grab such a huge chunk of slot revenues, the state may well be shooting itself in the foot.
DFS, which is taxed at 10.5 percent in New Jersey gets off relatively easy in Pennsylvania, however, where operators will pay a modest 15 percent.
NJ vs PA taxes and fees
Here’s a look at the difference in taxes and fees for the two states:
|iGaming License Fee||$400,000||$10,000,000|
|iGaming Annual Fee||$250,000||-|
|iGaming Tax Rate||17.5%||55% Slots/16% Table Games /16% Poker|
|B&M Casino Tax Rate||9.25%||55% Slots/16% Table Games|
|DFS Tax Rate||10.5%||15%|
Subscribe to get the latest NJ online casino and sports betting news to your inbox.